Since the early 20th Century, Chinese nationalism has been at the heart of Chinese culture, largely as a consequence of the fear and distrust that manifested itself as a reaction to Western Imperialism and outside threats after the fall of the Qing Dynasty. Following civil war, revolution and years of Communist rule, nationalism is one of the key threads that has remained constant throughout modern China. However, what has Chinese nationalism developed into and what does it mean today? I want to know your thoughts!
The time has come to start writing my Sinology project for SOAS this year and I’ve decided to focus on Nationalism. The reasons for why are complicated yet fascinating and I will be sure to elaborate on my reaction to them when I complete the project. However, for now, read my proposal and let me know what your thoughts are in a comment or an e-mail.
Bearing in mind the initial thoughts laid out at the beginning of my post, what has Chinese nationalism developed into and what does it mean today? With the absence of a common enemy such as the Soviet Union with which the government can use to unite the people against in a nationalistic campaign, why is nationalism still so prevalent, even with the new generation? I’m going to focus on the following areas:
- China’s “Angry Youth” (“fen qing” 愤青) - the role of the new generation of Chinese nationalists and how they are using the internet to communicate, organise and spread nationalism.
- The cultivation of nationalism by the government and the consequent balancing act between controlling, but not upsetting, the populace should any policy be introduced that could directly harm national interests.
- China’s need to ‘prove itself’ on a modern stage. For example, when China completed its first spacewalk, the emphasis was all placed on how it compared to the earlier achievement of the USA, rather than measuring on its own merit. Is this an example of an inferiority complex?
- Incidences where nationalism has suddenly increased of its own accord. For example: the Olympics, the torch relays, the Sichuan earthquake, riots in Tibet, boycotting of foreign goods etc.
- What focal point will nationalism take now that the Olympics has finished? Will it continue to grow without the help of the government and, if so, what does that mean for political stability?
Let me know your thoughts. In the meantime, you may want to check out this article by Evan Osnos in the New Yorker for further reading.
Browse Timeline
Comments ( 2 )
Alex added these pithy words on Dec 24 08 at 2:01 amHey James, apologies if this is a bit late - its been a while since I checked to see what you were up to. Nationalism isn’t really my area, but since when could I not pass comment?
There’s quite a bit of interesting literature around for this, including various explanations for Chinese nationalism which I’m guessing you’re aware of, but I figured I may as well try and outline some of the basics if you’ve not really started on the project yet. Actually I was about to do that, but then I came across some of my lecture slides on the topic, so I’m just copying and pasting the relevant bits. (Therefore sources courtesy of Dr Yiyi Lu, University of Nottingham)
Suisheng Zhao (1998), “A State-Led Nationalism: The Patriotic Education Campaign in Post-Tiananmen China” - Zhao’s argument: “a vigorous official propaganda campaign in patriotic education was behind the seemingly spontaneous rise of Chinese nationalism in the 1990s. It could not easily emerge without Communist state sponsorship.”
Peter Hays Gries (2004), China’s New Nationalism: Pride, Politics, and Diplomacy.
Gries’s argument: “The 1990s witnessed the emergence of a genuinely popular nationalism in China that should not be conflated with state or official nationalism.” “Because the anti-foreign tenor of popular nationalism is largely the same as that of state nationalism, Western analysts have too frequently dismissed popular nationalists as puppets in the hands of the Communist elite. This view is a grave mistake. In China today, popular networks are challenging the state’s hegemony over nationalism, threatening to rupture the Chinese nation-state.”Tong Lam (2000), “Identity and Diversity: The Complexities and Contradictions of Chinese Nationalism”
Lam’s arguments: Chinese nationalism is not “an overarching notion shared by the state and the entire population.” Rather, it is “an agglomeration of political concerns, commercial interests, and consumer desires that may or may not be consonant with each other.”
Lam says that often commercial interests use nationalism to serve their purposes, e.g., fast-food restaurant using the slogan “Chinese should dine with chopsticks” to compete with the neighbouring McDonald’s.
Lam also thinks that consumerism and materialistic pursuit lead to a sense of the loss of cultural identity and tradition. The very meaning of Chineseness is being called into question. This cultural anxiety gives impetus to nationalism.This next one might be pretty useful if you look to the “angry youth” angle and internet communications
Xu Wu (2007), Chinese Cyber Nationalism: Evolution, Characteristics, and Implications.
Wu defines Chinese cyber nationalism as “a non-government sponsored ideology and movement that has originated, existed, and developed in China’s online sphere over the past decade (1994-present)…It is different from both the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) official version of patriotism, and the traditional Chinese nationalism movement. Taking advantage of the online communication technology, Chinese cyber nationalists have been utilizing the Internet as a communication center, organizational platform, and execution channel to promote the nationalistic causes among Chinese people around the world. They focus primarily on those international issues involving China and strive to retain China’s historical status as a respectable power.”There was also a poem I quite liked floating around a while back - theres a translated version over at CDT http://chinadigitaltimes.net/2008/04/my-friends-what-do-you-want-from-us/
Obviously there’s a bit of interpreting and arguing you can do both ways on that one, but I liked it, so I thought I’d throw it in.
Anyway, I hope the project goes well, I’d be quite interested in a read when its done and don’t mind proof reading if you need too.
Have a good Christmas if nothing else,
Alex
james added these pithy words on Dec 24 08 at 7:06 amAlex,
Thanks for that information, that’s brilliant. I’ll look into it and let you know what I find.
I’ve since managed to meet up with Evan Osnos from the New Yorker and borrow a few books from him surrounding the topic. I’m in the middle of getting my head round it all but, once I have something clear, I’ll be updating again.
Thanks again for your ideas mate. Merry Communist Christmas by the way!

